Fake #1


This coin was purchased on eBay in mid 2016 and the seller disclosed that it was fake and to be used in magic tricks.  We purchased it as a study piece and challenged the seller after we had it in hand about ethics.


True to form the seller's defense was "It isn't illegal to make and sell coins that are no longer in circulation."  An interesting defense and when we told him we were thinking about turning him in to the Secret Service he disappeared for a while.  But like most crooks he came back after a little nap time.


The coin is probably a steel alloy of some description.  It is light and responds to a magnet.  Also like some others we have seen it does not hold detail well, perhaps indicating it is too hard to easily strike.


Strike Errors

When we looked at the coin we knew it was a fake because the reverse is from a different year.  The 1881-O has only one style of mint mark and it is oval.  The mint mark on this coins is round.


On VAMworld someone suggested that this might be a sand cast which we had not considered.  But this has some credibility for an unusual error that would not be present in a steel die.


At first we thought we were seeing horns on Liberty's head and then we internalized the sand cast comment.  If the coin were cast in this way then it might have been made on a reused sand cast where a Peace Dollar was first produced.  Liberty has rays that come from the head that would just about line up with these and perhaps that is the source.


There is another blaring error in the headband where the word LIBERTY fades out toward the bottom right.

Click on either image for a larger view


The Aging 1D


Clashed Denticle

Date Issues


New Orleans and the Mint in 1881

The Devolving 5

One and Done

Two and Through


Die Fingerprints


The Devolving 27


A coin like this cannot be VAMed because the reverse is unknown.  However, we did have a little fun speculating about what die might have been used on the obverse and made this little analytical comment on VAMworld.


"The hair curls limit the VAM to 1F, 8, 24, 26, 26A, 35, 37A, 37B, 40, 51, 65, 68


There is no spike in the first 8, so we are left with 1F, 8, 24, 35, 37A, 37B, 51, 65, 68


It isn't clashed so we are left with 1F, 8, 24, 35, 37B, 65, 68


I don't see any obvious date doubling which leaves 1F, 8, 37B


I don't see the field pitting of the 1F but need to pull the coin


If there is no pitting in the right field then we can narrow this to 8 and 37B


These are dependent (as is the 8) on reverse characteristics and since we don't have a real reverse this is as close as we can get."